Tag Archives: reading

CAN YOU RECOMMEND ANY RESOURCES OR REFERENCES FOR FURTHER READING ON CAPSTONE PROJECTS IN PHYSICS

Capstone projects are an important part of the physics curriculum as they allow students to demonstrate their skills and knowledge by taking on an independent research or design project by the end of their studies. This project is intended to showcase what students have learned throughout their physics education. Here are some recommendations for resources that can provide guidance on capstone projects in physics:

The American Physical Society provides a helpful overview page on their website about undergraduate physics capstone experiences. They describe the purpose of capstones as integrating skills and concepts learned across the curriculum by having students work independently on a project. They suggest capstones involve asking a research question, reviewing the literature, designing and carrying out an experiment or computational work, analyzing results, and presenting findings. The APS page lists examples of potential capstone topics and includes links to reports from various universities on their capstone programs. This is a good starting point for understanding best practices in capstone design.

The Council on Undergraduate Research is another excellent resource that publishes the journal Council on Undergraduate Research Quarterly which often features articles on capstone experiences and research in different disciplines including physics. A 2019 article discusses strategies for effective capstone program design and assessment based on a survey of departments. It outlines key components like defining learning outcomes, providing faculty support and guidance, emphasizing oral and written communication skills, and assessing student work. This provides a framework for developing a robust capstone experience.

Individual universities also share details of their successful physics capstone programs. For example, the University of Mary Washington published a report on revisions made to their capstone seminar course to better scaffold the research process. They emphasize starting early in the planning stages, utilizing research mentors, implementing interim deadlines, and incorporating oral presentations. Their model could be replicated at other primarily undergraduate institutions.

Virginia Tech published recommendations specifically for experimental and computational physics capstones. They suggest identifying faculty research projects that align with student interests and skill levels. For experimental work, they stress the importance of carefully designing the experiment, taking and analyzing quality data, and discussing sources of error and uncertainty. For computational projects, they recommend clearly outlining the scientific problem and modeling approach. Both provide valuable guidance for mentoring physics capstone work.

The Joint Task Force on Undergraduate Physics Programs also provides a case study of redesigned capstone experiences at several universities. They examine the role of capstones in assessing if programs are meeting stated learning goals as well as strategies for implementing change based on program reviews. The case studies give concrete examples of reworked capstone curricula, resources, and assessment practices. This is useful for departments evaluating how to strengthen existing capstone offerings.

For sources focused on project ideation, the physics departments at universities like Carnegie Mellon, William & Mary, and James Madison have compiled lists of example past successful student capstone projects. Reviewing these can spark new research questions and ideas that are well-suited to a capstone timeframe and scope. Browsing conference proceedings from groups like the American Association of Physics Teachers can also uncover current topics and methods in experimental and theoretical physics well-aligned with an undergraduate skillset.

There are many best practice resources available to aid in the development and implementation of effective capstone experiences that enable physics students to showcase their expertise through independent research or design work by the end of their studies. Looking to organizations like the APS and CUR as well as capstone program descriptions and case studies from individual universities provides a wealth of guidance on structuring successful capstone experiences.